The honeymoon ended before the winter frost could thaw. When Xabi Alonso arrived in June 2025, fresh off a tactical masterclass with Bayer Leverkusen, he was hailed as the “Prodigal Son” destined to define an era. Fast forward to January 2026, and the Spaniard is out. The Real Madrid managerial crisis has struck again, claiming a club legend after just eight months. The trigger? A 3-2 Supercopa defeat to Barcelona in Jeddah—a “Capital Offense” in the eyes of the board that outweighed a solid second-place standing in La Liga. This isn’t just a bad run of form; it’s a symptom of a “President-centric” model that prioritizes brand over tactical continuity. At the Bernabéu, the manager is often treated as a temporary caretaker for a collection of stars rather than the architect of a long-term project.
The Institutional Flaw: The “Untouchable” President
At the heart of the Real Madrid managerial crisis lies a 21-year shadow: Florentino Pérez. In the modern game, most elite clubs employ a buffer—a Sporting Director who harmonizes the coach’s tactical needs with the board’s financial goals. At Real Madrid, that buffer doesn’t exist. Pérez is the architect, the financier, and the ultimate arbiter of the media narrative. This “Imperial Presidency” ensures that when results dip, the blame is funneled downward toward the dugout rather than outward toward the boardroom. Without a traditional club structure, elite coaches like Alonso, Ancelotti, and Benitez fail not on the grass, but in the political corridors where they must “manage upward” to survive.
| Manager | Tenure | Primary Exit Trigger | League Position at Exit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carlo Ancelotti | 2021–2025 | Lack of Domestic Dominance | 2nd |
| Xabi Alonso | 2025–2026 | Supercopa Loss / Tactical Friction | 2nd |
| Álvaro Arbeloa | 2026–Present | Interim Appointment | N/A |
Squad Planning Mirage: “Galácticos” Over Balance – Real Madrid Managerial Crisis
Why does Real Madrid keep failing to find stability? The squad rebuild has consistently prioritized “Shiny Objects” over structural integrity. Alonso’s system at Leverkusen thrived on a defensive anchor, yet his pleas for a player like Martin Zubimendi were ignored in favor of the €60m “next big thing” in attack. The obsession with Florentino Pérez‘s “Galáctico” vision has left the squad drowning in elite attackers like Mbappé and Vinícius Jr., but starving for defensive depth at CB and RB. This creates a “top-heavy” trap where coaches are forced to fit big names into unnatural positions, leading to friction and inevitable tactical collapse. When the system breaks, the board points to the coach’s “training methods” rather than their own failures in transfer policy.
The Dressing Room Power Shift and the Interim Trap – Real Madrid Managerial Crisis
In the hierarchy of the Bernabéu, player power often holds more leverage than the man with the whistle. The authority of the manager is constantly undermined by a board that treats star players as untouchable brands. Following the October Clásico fallout, it became clear that a player’s brand value carries more weight than tactical discipline. This shift leads the board to retreat into the “Interim Trap,” appointing “House Men” like Álvaro Arbeloa who understand the club’s values but lack the power to demand structural changes. These appointments act as a shield for the board, distracting fans with nostalgia while the underlying La Liga problems and organizational instability remain unaddressed.
Conclusion: Why the Real Madrid Managerial Crisis Will Continue
Until the club adopts a modern sporting structure that empowers the manager over the “stars,” the Real Madrid managerial crisis is destined to repeat. The manager has become a convenient scapegoat for an imbalanced squad, a lack of defensive recruitment, and a boardroom that views football as a marketing exercise. As Pérez approaches his 80s, his desire for instant “Jewel in the Crown” success creates a volatile environment where no project can take root. While the manager sacked headlines provide a temporary distraction, the true solution lies in organizational reform. Until Real Madrid prioritizes sporting logic over presidential whims, the cycle of sacking legends will continue, regardless of the name on the dugout.
About the Author
